Home - Mayville Insurance Agency, Inc.
Personal Coverage - Homeowners, Condo / Renters, Seasonal Property, Automobile, Personal Umbrella, Boats, Recreational Vehicles ,Valuable Property, Mobile / Motor Homes, Flood
Business Coverage, Property, General Liability,Worker’s Compensation, Automobile, Businessowners, Contract / Surety Bonds, Professional Liability, Umbrella Liability, Boiler & Machinery, Inland Marine
Financial Services, Life Insurance, Disability Plans, Group & Individual Health Policies
About Mayville Insurance Agency. Mayville Insurance Agency, Inc. was established in 1947. As an independent insurance agency, we choose from a select group of leading insurance companies for your insurance needs, not just one.
Mayville Insurance Agency Inc. has a friendly staff that is willing to serve you.
Mayville Insurance Agency Inc. has an array of  hot topics including the following: The Stella Awards,Black Box Article, Credit Scoring, Protect Against Identity Theft, Identity Theft A Growing Concern, Protecting Family and Property During Storm and Flood Season, Back to School, Fire Safety
Mayville Insurance Agency, Inc., 34 S. Main Street, PO Box 272, Mayville, WI 53050, Phone: (920) 387-2140, Fax (920) 387-4449

Mayville Insurance Agency, Inc. office hours, 8:00 a.m to 5 p.m, Monday through  Friday, and by appointment.

Picture – Brad Steinbach - Owner
Brad Steinbach

I joined my fathers business in 1976. Since that time, I obtained my insurance license and in 1984, earned the Certified Insurance Counselor designation (CIC). In 1994, I took ownership of Mayville Insurance Agency.

I have been very active in the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin. From 1995 to 2001 I served on the PIA of Wisconsin Board of Directors. During that time, I volunteered on many committees including membership, agents service, convention and education. I was elected to the executive board and served as President from 1997-1998. In 1998 I was chosen by my peers as the Professional Agent of the Year.

Born and raised in Mayville, I attend Mayville High School. My education continued at the University of Wisconsin, Oshkosh where I majored in business.

Community involvement has been very important. I am a past president of the Mayville Chamber of Commerce and past president of the Mayville Rotary Club. Through Rotary, I was recognized as a Paul Harris Fellow. I remain very active in Rotary currently serving on the scholarship, rose sale and wine-tasting committees.

As an avid sportsman, duck hunting and fishing are passions of mine. I also enjoy a good round of golf.

My wife Cindy and I live in Mayville and are the proud parents of two children, Leslie and Craig.

Please feel free to contact me at bsteinbach@mayvilleinsurance.com


Picture – Cindy Steinbach – Owner
Cindy Steinbach

I started my career in the insurance industry in 1990. As a licensed agent, I hold the CISR (Certified Insurance Service Representative) and CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) designations. My husband Brad and I are partners in this family owned business. I oversee the Personal Lines Team, computer needs and office management.
I was born and raised in the Mayville area and attended Mayville High School. My continued education included Moraine Park Technical Institute where I obtained an associate degree in Computer Programming. In 1987, I received my insurance license. Prior to joining Mayville Insurance Agency, I worked for the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin (PIAW).
2004-2005 PIA Board of Directors
Cindy speaking at PIA State Convention
I have served on many PIAW committees; membership, automation, agents service, convention and education. In 2000, I received the distinguished Stony Steinbach Achievement Award. Currently I am on the Executive Committee and hold the position of Treasurer.
Community involvement is a big part of my life. I have co-chaired Mayville’s community fall festival, Audubon Days, for 7 years. In 1999, I was selected as Mayville’s Citizen of the Year. Currently, I am the Vice-President of the Mayville Chamber of Commerce.

My husband Brad and I live in Mayville and are the proud parents of two children, Leslie and Craig.

Please feel free to contact me at csteinbach@mayvilleinsurance.com.



Picture - Tracy Thoreson
Tracy Thoreson

I have been employed by Mayville Insurance Agency since 2000 in the Commercial Lines Department. Since then I obtained my insurance license and hold the CISR designation (Certified Insurance Service Representative). Over the years I have enjoyed the many challenges of working in the insurance industry and the relationships I have established with my Commercial Lines Customers.

I was born and raised in Mayville and graduated from Mayville High School in 1998. Prior to joining Mayville Insurance Agency I was a Certified Nursing Assistant at the Mayville Nursing & Rehabilitation Center and was also employed by TSB Bank in Theresa.

I currently live in Mayville with my husband Eric and our daughter Kyra. Kyra was born July 9, 2002 and is a wonderful addition to our family.

Please feel free to contact me at tthoreson@mayvilleinsurance.com.


34 S. Main Street | PO Box 272 | Mayville, WI 53050 | Phone: (920) 387-2140 | Fax (920) 387-4449

© Copyright 2008 Mayville Insurance. All Rights Reserved.