Mayville Insurance

Mayville West Bend
  • Home
  • Staff
    • Brad Steinbach, CIC
    • Cindy Steinbach CIC, CISR
    • Michele Schultz, CIC, CISR
    • Leslie Palleria, CISR
    • Melody Breen
    • Callee Strook
    • Jenny Harbin, CISR
    • Teresa Manthey
  • Reviews
  • Insurance
    • Car Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Boat Insurance
    • Motorcycle Insurance
    • RV, Trailer and ATV Insurance
    • Umbrella Insurance
    • Flood Insurance
    • Business Insurance
    • Contractors Insurance
    • Restaurant & Tavern Insurance
  • Locations
    • Mayville
    • West Bend
  • Service
  • News
    • Our Blog
    • Mayville Newsletters
  • Refer a Friend
  • Quote
  • Newsletter Drawing Winner

    Congratulations to Tyler Henning, he was our January Newsletter Drawing Winner. Tyler received a gift certificate to Leroy Meats. He was presented his … Learn More...

    Newsletter Drawing Winner
  • Customer Service

    At Mayville Insurance, we strive to deliver the high-quality customer service that we would expect ourselves. Our Door is Always Open We’re … Learn More...

    Customer Service
  • Business Insurance

    All businesses need insurance, but the amount and types of coverage required will vary. For some businesses, the coverage needs may not be extensive. … Learn More...

    Business Insurance
  • Home Insurance

    Your house is one of your most prized – and expensive – possessions. Protect it with a Wisconsin home insurance policy that goes the extra mile for … Learn More...

    Home Insurance
  • Car Insurance

    If you’ve ever had to file a claim on your car insurance, you know how invaluable this critical coverage can be. If you have never had to use your … Learn More...

    Car Insurance
american-strategic
imt
wilson-mutual
Society
RPS
integrity
foremost-ins
westbend
WisconsinMutual
aaa
Acuity-Logo-120x100-Transparent
american-collectors
american-modern2
progressive

Car Insurance

Family in a minivan

If you’ve ever had to file a claim on your car insurance, you know how invaluable this critical coverage can be. If you have never had to use your coverage, it just might save you tens of thousands of dollars in repair and liability costs one day. Here at Mayville Insurance, we help Wisconsin … Learn More...

Home Insurance

Kitchen interior of a nice house

Your house is one of your most prized – and expensive – possessions. Protect it with a Wisconsin home insurance policy that goes the extra mile for you and your family. Here at Mayville Insurance, we know how quickly a home and everything in it can be lost in a fire. We also know how devastating it … Learn More...

Small Business Insurance

A carpenter carrying a load of wood

All businesses need insurance, but the amount and types of coverage required will vary. For some businesses, the coverage needs may not be extensive. For those with multiple locations, many employees, or operating in high-risk industries, however, the insurance needs may be more complex. At Mayville … Learn More...

Contractors Insurance

Self employeed contractor building a deck

No two days in the life of a contractor are the same. Every job brings a different set of problems and risks; the last thing you need to be worried about is whether you are covered against a possible loss. Contractor’s insurance helps to minimize your risk exposure, allowing you to spend more time … Learn More...

About Mayville Insurance

Brad and Cindy Steinbach - Mayville Insurance

Welcome to Mayville Insurance

Mayville Insurance is an independent insurance agency with offices in Mayville and West Bend, WI.

Our agency was founded in 1947 by E. "Stony" Steinbach, father to our current co-owner, Brad Steinbach. Stony was not only the local independent agent in Mayville, he was also instrumental in the formation and growth of the Wisconsin Professional Insurance Agents (PIA), serving as Executive Secretary for more than 40-years.

From the very beginning, Mayville Insurance has been focused on serving the individuals, families, and businesses of Mayville, as well as Dodge, Washington, and Fond du Lac Counties.

Unlike some agencies, we take the time to get to know our policyholders and really do treat them like family. When you call our office, you'll be sure to be greeted by a friendly voice, and not an answering machine. It's the little things such as this that have generations of local families choose to do business with us. If you are new to the area, we'd like to welcome you, and hope that you are finding the people of the Mayville area neighborly as we strive to be.

If you have a question about your insurance, feel free to give us a call at either our Mayville or West Bend Office!

Request an Agent
Mayville Insurance

Our Free Newsletter!

Testimonials

Best Insurance Agency!

James Herget

I’ve had all my insurance thru Mayville for years. The couple of claims I’ve had were handled fast a…

Adele Walker

A great agency. Have never encountered problems.

Sandra Finke

Mayville Insurance has been taking care of our insurance needs for a few years now. They found the b…

Rick Lisa B

Exceptional Customer Service!

Diana Unger

I have found the staff at Mayville Insurance to be very courteous and responsive to my questions and…

Wes Gayan

Almost 15 years of great service. They switched me to a different home insurance because they didn’t…

Diane

Best rates out there! For your cars and home. Best agents who care.and work for you. Go beyond the …

Maria Stanard

Excellent job done!

Mary Nitschke

All of my questions and concerns are answered in a timely manner.

Megan Jacoby

Two Locations!

1784 Horicon St
Mayville, WI 53050
Phone: 920-387-2140

143 S Main St - First Floor
West Bend, WI 53095
Phone: 262-247-8045

Our Hours

Mayville Hours
Monday - Friday 8:00 - 5:00
Saturday & Sunday
By Appointment

West Bend Hours
Monday - Friday 8:30 - 5:00
Evenings By Appointment

Proud Member of

Follow Us

Facebooklinkedinyoutube
Copyright © 2019 - Mayville Insurance Agency, Inc. - Terms and Conditions - Privacy Policy - Sitemap