Mayville Insurance - Mayville, Wisconsin

Newsletter Drawing Winner
Congratulations to Andrea Heintz, she was our Newsletter Drawing Winner. Andrea received a gift card from Leroy Meats. She was presented her gift … Learn More...
Customer Service
At Mayville Insurance, we strive to deliver the high-quality customer service that we would expect ourselves. Our Door is Always Open We’re … Learn More...
Business Insurance
All businesses need insurance, but the amount and types of coverage required will vary. For some businesses, the coverage needs may not be extensive. … Learn More...
Home Insurance
Your house is one of your most prized – and expensive – possessions. Protect it with a Wisconsin home insurance policy that goes the extra mile for … Learn More...
Car Insurance
If you’ve ever had to file a claim on your car insurance, you know how invaluable this critical coverage can be. If you have never had to use your … Learn More...

Welcome to Mayville Insurance

Mayville Insurance is an independent insurance agency with offices in Mayville and West Bend, WI.

Our agency was founded in 1947 by E. "Stony" Steinbach, father to our current co-owner, Brad Steinbach. Stony was not only the local independent agent in Mayville, he was also instrumental in the formation and growth of the Wisconsin Professional Insurance Agents (PIA), serving as Executive Secretary for more than 40-years.

From the very beginning, Mayville Insurance has been focused on serving the individuals, families, and businesses of Mayville, as well as Dodge, Washington, and Fond du Lac Counties.

Unlike some agencies, we take the time to get to know our policyholders and really do treat them like family. When you call our office, you'll be sure to be greeted by a friendly voice, and not an answering machine. It's the little things such as this that have generations of local families choose to do business with us. If you are new to the area, we'd like to welcome you, and hope that you are finding the people of the Mayville area neighborly as we strive to be.

If you have a question about your insurance, feel free to give us a call at either our Mayville or West Bend Office!

This is an excellent insurance company to work with. Friendly staff, timely answers and great customer service! Highly recommended!

Tiffanie Kloida R.

16:01 19 Mar 20

Very professional, knowledgeable, fast and friendly. Thank you for all you do.

Brenda D.

14:16 19 Mar 20

Mayville Insurance Agency has been so helpful since day 1! When we bought our 1st house in 2012, they helped us by showing all the possible insurance coverage we needed. We also discussed car insurance. MIA provided the best rate for the best coverage. Anytime we had questions or needed additional coverage, they were there with answers. Nothing like local and fast support! Thank you all!

Ashley H.

22:03 23 Jan 20

Ashley H.

22:00 23 Jan 20

The friendly, knowledgeable people who give us 100% every step of the way! Michele Schultz you are the greatest! I love your personality. Thanks for taking such good care of us.

Sandra L C.

17:07 08 Jan 20

Knowledgeable, friendly, fair and fast! Cindy and Mayville Insurance are 2nd to none! Thanks

William E.

18:39 12 Dec 19

I have been insured by the Steinbachs since 1969. Never an issue or a problem. No obstruction, collusion or quid pro quo, just great service.

Jeffrey L.

21:51 20 Nov 19

Brad and Cindy go above and beyond for their clients. You never have to wonder if you could be getting a better rate because they proactively tell you! I own a bar & grill and they make a point to come see us every year. How many insurance agents do you know that do that? None that I know! I appreciate their loyalty and proactive approach to taking care of their clients. I’ll never switch!

Lisa Pfeil P.

21:13 18 Nov 19

Great friendly staff service combined with the quest to reduce my premiums.

Daniel K.

16:37 25 Oct 19

First started with them married with a house, car, truck and a boat they saved us money. After a divorce and now renting with two motorcycles, a truck and a car they are still saving me money. They are super helpful and friendly.

Alex C.

10:42 25 Oct 19

They have big hearts and made us realize how much we love living in a small town. They were there for us 100% when we needed them most.

Eden V.

23:11 22 Sep 19

Excellent customer service

gl0ck P.

17:58 10 Sep 19

Going above and beyond every month.

Terry S.

11:56 10 Sep 19

My husband and I have had a few unforeseen issues this year that have caused us to have to contact Mayville Insurance. The staff is stellar! Michele is always so helpful and quick to get things taken care of so we can be on our way!

Michele S.

14:36 16 Aug 19

Always there when you need them.

Scott H.

15:09 13 Jun 19

Staff are very responsive and always helpful

Tiffany W.

13:10 13 Jun 19

Great customer service,helping in every way from new coverage, renewals and claims. highly reccomend.

Lori L.

14:34 14 May 19

Mayville Insurance is concern about your needs and how to best service you. Teresa made it so easy for us to change insurance. I really enjoyed my experience and you will too! Thank you!

Penny M.

20:20 27 Apr 19

Top notch service! Helping in every way, from renewals to claims and everything in between!

Dawn N.

18:59 24 Apr 19

Very happy to be working at Mayville Insurance Agency.

Marjorie P.

21:43 20 Apr 19

They will contribute all there efforts to serve the customer promptly.

Ian G.

15:25 21 Feb 19

Always interested in our concerns about all of our "stuff". Willing, friendly, and capable of filling our needs. So glad we are one of your clients. Thank you for all that you will do for us at anytime.

Jan Wally L.

15:06 21 Feb 19

Always friendly and on top of things! Mayville Insurance is always making sure we have the proper coverage. After the storm last year, they were on the phone right away to make sure we were OK and to determine if they needed to send out an adjuster.

Susan Daniel G.

14:58 21 Feb 19

I have been with Mayville Insurance over 20+ years and they have done a good job for me over the years

Tracie R.

14:22 02 Feb 19

Great to work with! Very helpful with any questions I've had regarding my coverage. Highly recommend!!

Rachael T.

18:04 17 Dec 18

Love the experience I get from them, professional fast service.

Leon R.

22:41 18 Sep 18

Mayville Insurance is very easy to work with and they are always finding the best "deals" in insurance for us. When you have multiple cars to cover and some are seasonal and changing all the time, they can handle it!! We are very pleased with them, always on the ball!! Thank you, Mayville Insurance!!

Mary C.

16:47 23 Aug 18

Jenny Harbin was wonderful in meeting all of my needs in a timely manner with my best interest in mind. She was able to save me more than $300 yearly for my auto insurance. Highly recommend Mayville Insurance and Jenny Harbin as an insurance specialist.

Ashley L.

23:03 13 Aug 18

Amazing service! Especially from my agent Teresa! I highly recommend her. Thank you for a level of customer service you rarely see!

Jenny S.

02:17 09 Aug 18

Love the service we have had with Mayville Insurance. We have been with them for many years. Always finding better rates to fit your needs with different companies. They are very friendly and helpful with any situation that comes up.

Lori A.

12:42 30 Jul 18

My family has had Mayville Insurance since I can remember. Great customer service and a pleasure to work with! Highly recommended.

Christina M.

20:01 25 Jul 18

We've been very pleased with Mayville Insurance Agency. We've been with them for many years and they are always one step ahead of the game with our insurance needs. I would highly recommend them as they have great customer service, quick to respond and will find the best coverage possible for you!

Nicole K.

18:23 25 Jul 18

Extremely friendly and helpful

Stacey M.

18:22 25 Jul 18

Mayville has been my insurance agency for 18 years and has been outstanding in every way. The advice and counsel I have received has been outstanding and Cindy and Brad have found the best people to continue their outstanding performance. Michele is a great example of what wonderful customer service should be.

Anthony Jackson W.

15:19 18 Jul 18

Easy to work with(mostly handled through emails), great customer service, great at finding the best rates, filed a claim once and it was flawless. I have recommended them to several people already and will continue to.

Dan R.

00:59 22 Jun 18

The best possible insurance company around in all possible ways!!

Sam S.

20:27 21 Jun 18

Mayville Insurance Agency is very friendly and helpful. Never had to make a claim. But we have had a lot of changes with our vehicles.

Tracey P.

21:45 23 May 18

Mayville Insurance is great, they always find the best deal for you. I saved over 400 a year for the same Insurance I had through AARP. Take the time and do some research with Mayviile, you'll be glad you did.

Nancy H.

12:57 22 May 18

The people at Mayville Insurance give me prompt and courteous service. They have been working with me for the last five years I wouldn't go through anyone else. They truly do care and they get back to you in a very timely fashion with any questions you may have. I highly recommend Mayville Insurance.

Chrissy K.

23:09 21 May 18

Great insurance company. I've been with mayville insurance for over 7 years. The always take the time to inform me of the best, most affordable rates.

Stephanie B.

19:41 21 May 18

I have been a customer of Mayville Insurance for almost 10 years now. I always receive friendly, timely, and excellent service from the whole Mayville Insurance Team!

Sean N.

16:38 24 Apr 18

Michelle has been bending over backwards to see us completely through the aftermath of a car accident in which our car was totaled. Thank you so much, Michelle! We would recommend you to others!

Geri F.

17:04 27 Mar 18

Mayville Insurance is always making sure we have the best rates. The staff is super friendly. Recommend to everyone!

Julie S.

15:25 27 Mar 18

Love this Insurance Agency!!!! Friendly, knowledgeable staff!!! They know who you are as soon as you call!!!!! Love the fact they are ALWAYS helping you find the best insurance coverage!!!!

Jessie G.

14:52 27 Mar 18

I absolutely love this company. They do what they can to find you the lowest rate, and are always prompt in responding to emails and phone calls. The staff all around is very friendly

Amanda W.

14:43 27 Mar 18

We have so many insurance policies at Mayville Insurance that we almost need insurance on our insurance. : ) Seriously, what I appreciate more than anything is the high level of professionalism, customer service and responsiveness over the many years. It's no wonder they've been in business so long.

Tracy H.

23:58 18 Mar 18

You leave the office with the feeling like you got a good friend who keeps an eye on you and gets you what you need not what the big companies are pushing. I dont worry about asking around to people at work what they are paying for Car and Home insurance , because when Mayville Insurance finds a better deal on a quality policy ,they notify me without me having to ask if there is something better. They are the pleasant part of having insurance and the by far the best agency Ive ever had.

Robert T.

20:35 26 Feb 18

Great customer service. Fantastic to do business with.

Julie G.

02:24 08 Feb 18

The staff at Mayville Insurance takes great care of us. Whether it's helping us renew our policy with best rates and coverage or reassuring us when we need to file a claim. They are always prompt, friendly, and helpful. We have been with them for many years now and are very satisfied.

Jack D.

15:19 27 Jan 18

Thank you for finding best insurance for us.

Wayne Susie M.

17:33 26 Jan 18

I have been with Mayville Insurance Agency for almost a year now. I work with Michele and she is awesome! Very prompt about returning emails and getting my requests completed. Always friendly and more than helpful!

Samantha W.

18:11 24 Jan 18

We have been very satisfied with Mayville Insurance right from the day we transitioned all of our insurance needs from a competitor. Always very fast and friendly service, which they have extended to our children as they grew up and required their own coverage. I refer Mayville Insurance to anyone who asks!

Debbie K.

01:45 23 Jan 18

I appreciate Mayville Insurance Agency. After using the same insurance provider for nearly a decade, I was tired of being let down by the staff I trusted to make sure I was taken care of in the event of an emergency or unforseen event. I switched to Mayville Insurance Agency when I bought my home and haven't looked back yet. They value their customers and look to find the best plan, for both quality and affordability, to accomodate your specific families' needs. I appreciate the beautiful clean office, the friendly staff, and the knowledgable agents who help me with my policy whenever questions arise. I would recommend them to anyone who wants to insure their assets.

Chelsie L.

16:45 21 Jan 18

I switched to Mayville Insurance about 1.5 years ago after a few bad experiences with my previous provider. They are so helpful and informative at Mayville Insurance. I appreciate the great customer service, the knowledge of the staff, and the reliability I can depend on from them. I have emailed a few times with random questions as life changes, and the responses I receive are thorough and timely. I would definitely recommend their services.

Tae F.

16:39 21 Jan 18

I have found the staff at mayville Insurance to be very courteous and responsive to my questions and concerns. I switched all of my vehicles and property insurance over to these people. Highly recommended

Wes G.

18:04 16 Jan 18

Excellent Insurance company that takes care of the customer with great advice and they are the most competitive and best priced around.Hands on and they are always there when you need them.I would invite you to shop around and find out that nobody can compete with them.

Brian C.

03:05 16 Jan 18

Best Insurance Agency !

James H.

17:03 09 Jan 18

Review from Bill and Sue Lee.Mayville Insurance Agency is professional, competent, and keeps their customers informed on needs for insurance they don't realize they should have. No pressure just good old commonsense explanations. We appreciate the follow up and periodic contact.Plus this company is engaged in the community and has provided hundreds of hours of community service. Said another way Mayville Insurance Agency is a great Corporate Citizen for Mayville and surrounding communities.Best regards Sue and Bill Lee. We are happy customers!!

Callee S.

14:24 22 Dec 17

Fast, Friendly and reliable. Every time I talked to anyone in the office it was dealt with prompt, professional courtesy. I've never felt like I wasn't important to the agency.

Bruce W.

19:28 21 Dec 17

Definitely 5 star. Doing business with them for many years. Stop in and say hi to the old guy if he's not hunting, fishing, golfing or drowning out gophers.

Jeff L.

17:47 05 Dec 17

They were great to work with and because they have multiple insurance quotes, they find you the best deal! Very happy with them!

Laurie A.

23:03 16 Nov 17

I've never had an insurance company that called me up to let me know I could reduce my premium with a simple tweak until I signed up with Mayville insurance. I love how professional they are. We have always gotten great service from all of their employees. Super company!

Rachel Heron R.

18:35 16 Nov 17

The reps at Mayville Insurance are very friendly and easy to work with. My agent has done a wonderful job setting up a policy tailored to my needs!

Alyssa T.

19:44 02 Nov 17

Top notch insurance agency!!!! Very informative, helpful, easy to file claims, & just an all around good staff & atmosphere!!!!! Would definitely recommend to anyone for all their insurance needs!!!!!

Kevin S.

23:05 23 Aug 17

Within the last year I switched all of my business and personal insurance policies over to Mayville Insurance. Jenny Harbin has been awesome to work with, making sure that every detail is taken care of. We recently had a loss and needed to make a claim. Jenny often called to check on the progress and to make sure that we were happy with the service that we were receiving from the insurance company. If I had questions regarding the claim, she personally called the company and got my answers. Mayville Insurance has outstanding service!

Nenno Products L.

17:43 15 Aug 17

A great agency. Have never encountered problems.

Sandra F.

17:39 10 Aug 17

Mayville insurance agency is a great place to have insurance through! They do whatever they can to save you money on insurance! I work crazy hours and they were willing to meet me on a Sunday to sign paperwork. What kind of place does that nowadays for you.

Mike S.

16:58 10 Aug 17

Almost 15 years of great service. They switched me to a different home insurance because they didn't like how the company handled problems. I have home and auto with them and nobody can match their yearly price. If I ever have a question there is always someone who can answer it for me. There are no complaints from me. :) Diane

Wishspell

07:51 19 Jul 17

Best Ins I have had in Years. It is so easy to compare prices with the internet. And the costumer service is great. Do your self a favor and do some compering, you won't be sorry!!!!!!!!

Robert K.

16:57 17 Jul 17

Great company, great service, and great people! I highly recommend Mayville insurance to everyone.

Todd K.

15:39 28 Jun 17

I have used Mayville Insurance for commercial and personal policies for years. I had joined a group of network referrals and changed my insurance and did I ever regret that. I came back to Tracy, as she really knows her job. She is VERY thorough at explaining everything and gets you the best commercial coverage you can get at the best price. My change to someone who did not have my personal best interest at heart, as Mayville insurance does, cost me a loss of over 30K. I would refer Mayville Insurance to anyone who wants great customer service, makes sure you are covered properly and even followed up to make sure coverage is working and to see if any questions. Best insurance company I have used in my 40 years. Thank you Tracy and Cindy for all of your help!

Julie H.

21:58 26 Jun 17

We previously had small town insurance agency that closed up, we so happy that Mayville Insurance Agency provides that personal small town touch that we love.

Lisa D.

18:25 26 Jun 17

I've had all my insurance thru Mayville for years. The couple of claims I've had were handled fast and efficiently. When I had a water pipe break on a Sunday they had a crew here within hours to start the repair process. I've always had awesome service from Mayville. They have always checked my renewal premiums and always checked and quoted the best insurance policy and premium they can find for me. I've already recommended them to other family and friends numerous times.

Adele W.

14:23 25 Jun 17

We have them for both business and personal insurance. Outstanding insurance agents. Great service and very punctual.

Joe W.

18:36 22 Jun 17

Are there actually other insurance agencies?? I've been with Mayville Insurance so long I forget about the "others". The reason for that is because at Mayville Insurance they do all the work for you. They always make sure I'm getting the best rate, the coverage I need, and that it's on time. The service over the last 20yrs has been phenomenal, and I'm looking forward to many more years with them.

jason B.

15:57 22 Jun 17

Mayville Insurance is superior in customer service! The staff is knowledgeable, friendly and they will "give it their all"" to satisfy their customers. I highly recommend them.

Susan R.

14:59 20 Jun 17

I have been with Mayville Insurance a long time because of great customer service. We work with Michelle, but have always been treated right by the whole staff. They personally went above what was expected to help me out. Thanks for everything!

Rhonda K.

02:40 14 Jun 17

Can't say enough positive things about Mayville Ins. Michele is always there to help, even if it a phone call with a question about something. Would refer anyone to them for ins.

Sharon W.

15:33 13 Jun 17

I've been using Mayville Insurance for as long as I can remember - probably since moving back to Theresa in 1998. For both home and auto insurance, I'm always confident of the best pricing out there. They even regularly review my policies and find better deals for me, without me requesting it! I sincerely appreciate that, as I'm generally too busy to do all that homework for myself. How great to know they've always got my back! Whenever I call or email with questions, I receive very prompt, friendly and professional responses. Owner Cindy Steinbach is especially wonderful with that! Honestly, I can't say enough about how great this agency, and the team there, is!

Sandra A.

14:41 29 May 17

Top notch Insurance Agency!

Judie H.

14:58 25 May 17

We have been with mayville ins for 30 plus years. Always looking out for us and inform us of changes that come along.

Brian V.

19:20 21 May 17

Have always had fast friendly service.

Becky G.

19:01 21 May 17

I highly recommend all my family and friends to Mayville Insurance! They have saved my family hundreds of dollars per year on insurance! They are by far the best insurance company I have ever worked with always friendly and fast!!!

Treena H.

02:11 21 May 17

Since moving to Mayville I have been using there insurance company. I am very pleased with the help they provide me with my insurance needs. When I needed to change my policies they do it right away and offer helpful suggestions and check for the best prices. Would highly recommend them to anyone needing insurance

Bill K.

15:58 19 May 17

Great people to work with.Prompt and friendly customer service anytime I may have a question.Great place to have all my insurance with.

Kurt S.

15:38 19 May 17

Exceptional Customer Service!

Diana U.

01:25 20 Apr 17

All of my questions and concerns are answered in a timely manner.

Megan J.

17:24 17 Apr 17

Great people to talk to they are very knowledgeable and respond quickly to your questions!!! Thank you for your dedication and service. Great people to work with!!!!

Nathan S.

13:46 14 Apr 17

Very professional and responsive to our needs.

Kathy B.

11:23 14 Apr 17

For the past 12 or so years that I have been a customer here they have been great. They have always found the most affordable rate for my car insurance. Five years ago when my wife and I bought a house they helped us with combining our home and auto. In all of my experience I definitely only have good things to say about this company

Richard C.

08:31 14 Apr 17

Mayville Insurance has been great to work with. They are always there to give us quotes and figure the best way to insure our stuff.

Jeff S.

01:54 14 Apr 17

We have been with them now for 6 years and they have always been wonderful! We are so happy to have a great business at our side when when need them!

Katie Del P.

22:51 13 Apr 17

Mayville Insurance has great customer service. They have a quick response time whenever I have questions.

Ashley S

21:59 13 Apr 17

Mayville Insurance has helped us greatly over the years! They find us the best rates, are easy to get in touch with and always keep us up to date with new changes or options that would suit our lifestyle.

Megan O.

20:19 13 Apr 17

Michele has been great to work with. Very knowledgeable staff and they helped our transition with insurance companies go smooth. I would highly recommend Mayville Insurance.

Jessica H.

20:04 13 Apr 17

My husband and I have trusted Mayville Insurance with all of our personal and business insurance needs for many years. I am completely confident that we are fully protected with the best possible policies to fit our needs and budget, and every time we have had a claim they have gone above and beyond to assist us through the process. I would not trust anyone else with protecting my business or my family!

Kim W.

19:26 13 Apr 17

I have been with Mayville Insurance for a number of years and have always been extremely happy with the company and the services they provide. Any questions or requests I have are always answered quickly and completely. I get all of my insurance through them and recommend them to anyone looking for a company that will do the research to get you exactly what you need at the best price that can be found.

Justin W.

22:55 27 Mar 17

The team at Mayville Insurance is very friendly and extremely knowledgeable. We recommend them to everyone.

Deana & Kurt N.

21:59 22 Mar 17

great company to deal with always friendly and there responses are fast.i have been with them for about 15 years now and they are always looking for the best deal us. thanks mayville insurance keep up the good work.

Shawn R.

21:35 22 Mar 17

They are always available when calling for questions and concerns. They are professional in making me feel that I am important to them.

Jackie D.

16:26 21 Mar 17

I highly recommend Mayville Insurance. They have helped me with many of my insurance needs. One call to them is all that is needed and they find the information I need. Because they are independent, they are able to find the best plans at the best cost for me. Everyone is friendly and very helpful.

Nancy W.

16:00 21 Mar 17

Been with them for over 40 years and they have never let me down. Very good people to work with.

Sandy Scheuers M.

15:05 21 Mar 17

I have been a happy customer with Mayville Insurance since 1998. They have been pleasant to work with and dependable in times of emergency.

Brian E.

14:23 21 Mar 17